While it might be possible to persuade some people of the absurdity of "trans women are women" by using methods like this, I think it's a fundamental misreading of the trans movement (or any other type of totalitarian ideology).
The absurdity and obvious falseness aren't a defect, it's the whole point. There's no use in pointing out the logical incoherence of being able to declare yourself the opposite sex but not a different race.
This stuff is about making it clear who sets the rules, no matter how arbitrary. Tyranny is always whimsical. The goal is to make enough people live with the lie, pay homage to it, and best of all celebrate it, and in that they have had a lot of success.
While it might be possible to persuade some people of the absurdity of "trans women are women" by using methods like this, I think it's a fundamental misreading of the trans movement (or any other type of totalitarian ideology).
The absurdity and obvious falseness aren't a defect, it's the whole point. There's no use in pointing out the logical incoherence of being able to declare yourself the opposite sex but not a different race.
This stuff is about making it clear who sets the rules, no matter how arbitrary. Tyranny is always whimsical. The goal is to make enough people live with the lie, pay homage to it, and best of all celebrate it, and in that they have had a lot of success.