Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Terry's avatar

I'd really like you to understand, Meghan. This post hurts feelings. MY SUFFERING IS UNIQUE.

"Do better."

Janice Fiamengo's avatar

If I like this, does that mean that I am mean and uncaring too?

I've never experienced depression, so that impairs me in responding to people who say they are experiencing it. I have definitely felt very sad, anxious, and despairing, but I've never found these to be particularly debilitating. I was always able to get my work done and complete necessary tasks. I've also been lucky in that I've always enjoyed the work that I was paid to do and knew that I did it competently.

I often feel trapped between wanting to be generally tolerant, and despairing of understanding so many people who seem completely ill-equipped for any kind of life at all. I wonder if they would simply have been left to die in the past. Perhaps they were better cared for by others when people lived in smaller communities and extended families, but I'm not sure. I doubt it.

Susanna Moodie's *Roughing It in the Bush,* a chronicle of the English author's life in the Ontario bush in the 1830s--rough farming, no running water, everything made by hand, no doctor, no police, no real government--tells of people who went mad in the bush. One guy drank himself into oblivion; another abandoned his wife and children, who were cared for by neighbors as best they could. I'm sure many people suffered horrifically. Moodie herself went through a terrible time with illnesses like ague. At one point, her husband had his leg broken when a tree fell on it while he was clearing their land. He dragged himself home and they set the leg themselves, and she cried because they weren't sure what would become of them with the man of the family unable to work. But they managed, barely, and she even wrote a book about her experiences at night while her children were sleeping.

I think there probably are conditions that worsen mental illness today: the very lack of any need to leave the house for weeks on end is surely itself debilitating and sick-making in its way, and endless screen time does weird things to our brains and emotions. At the same time, we have access to so much information that is enraging, enervating, and anxiety-producing, information that we can't really respond to in any proactive way. The Moodies didn't even know of the Rebellion of 1837 until it was almost at their doorstep. Moodie's husband signed up immediately to fight for the British government, and this was a good thing because it meant that they were getting a monthly stipend for the first time in years despite the risk to his life (he survived it). The loss of religious faith and broken families are also surely huge factors in our time; and many forces that deliberately demean and demoralize. Non-stop rage news can't help. The more I read of that, the more I dislike my fellow man and have to watch some animal videos to compensate, and to remind myself that there are still good people in the world and reasons for joy.

13 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?