Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joe Santucci's avatar

I thought this was one post worth reading again, so I read it to my teenage son. He’s been commenting about Swiftmania for the past couple years: “I don’t get it. Everyone likes her but me. I think she sucks.”

He also made a great point: “I really wonder, if it was the 70s when you had to be really good to reach that many people, if Taylor Swift would have made it [he’s a musician and adores Karen Carpenter’s voice]. I think modern tech may have something to do with it. She’s just the meme craze of teenage girls, who think they like her ‘cause they think everyone likes her. But marketing and algorithms are the force behind that popularity, not talent.”

Expand full comment
Amal's avatar

It's not that I'm a swift fan or think she's some kind of savant, it's that this piece just kind of comes off as petty. We get it, you don't think her music is good or she's worth all the accolades etc but you're kind of giving off an "old woman yells at cloud" vibe lol. I prefer Hole, Fiona Apple, people who don't have the musical range of a tea spoon but Swift's music appeals to a lot of people.

Expand full comment
59 more comments...

No posts